marwan/agdar

Fork 0

Marwan Alwali f31362093e update

2025-11-02 16:38:29 +03:00

21 KiB

Raw Blame History

Internal Notifications Assessment Report

AgdarCentre Healthcare Platform

Date: November 2, 2025
Assessed By: Cline AI Assistant

📊 Executive Summary

The AgdarCentre project implements a dual-layer notification system:

External Notifications (SMS/WhatsApp/Email) - For patient communications ✅ Fully Implemented
Internal Notifications (In-app) - For staff communications ❌ Critical Gap Identified

Overall Status: 70% Complete
Critical Issue: In-app notification model is missing, causing all internal staff notifications to fail silently.

🏗️ System Architecture

Notification Flow

User Action (e.g., Book Appointment)
    ↓
Django Signal (post_save)
    ↓
Signal Handler (appointments/signals.py)
    ↓
Celery Task (core/tasks.py)
    ↓
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│  Multi-Channel Notification         │
├─────────────────────────────────────┤
│ • In-App (❌ Model Missing)         │
│ • Email (✅ Working)                │
│ • SMS (✅ Working)                  │
│ • WhatsApp (✅ Working)             │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
    ↓
Message/Notification Record Created
    ↓
Provider Integration (Twilio/Unifonic)
    ↓
Delivery Status Tracking

✅ Implemented Components

1. External Notification System

Location: notifications/ app

Models (`notifications/models.py`)

MessageTemplate
- Reusable message templates
- Bilingual support (English/Arabic)
- Variable substitution system
- Channel-specific (SMS/WhatsApp/Email)
- Active/inactive status
Message
- Outbound message tracking
- Status lifecycle: QUEUED → SENT → DELIVERED → FAILED
- Provider integration (Twilio/Unifonic)
- Retry logic (max 3 attempts)
- Cost tracking
- Delivery timestamps
NotificationPreference
- Patient-specific preferences
- Channel preferences (SMS/WhatsApp/Email)
- Notification type preferences
- Language preference (EN/AR)
- Preferred channel priority
MessageLog
- Detailed audit trail
- Event tracking (Created, Queued, Sent, Delivered, Failed, Read, Retry)
- Provider response storage
- Error message capture

Messaging Service (`integrations/messaging_service.py`)

Key Features:

Template-based messaging with variable substitution
Multi-channel delivery (SMS, WhatsApp, Email)
Automatic delivery tracking
Patient preference checking
Retry logic for failed messages
Bulk messaging capabilities
Status synchronization with providers

Main Methods:

MessagingService:
  - send_from_template()      # Send using template
  - send_message()             # Send direct message
  - update_message_status()    # Sync with provider
  - retry_failed_message()     # Retry failed sends
  - send_bulk_messages()       # Bulk sending
  - get_message_statistics()   # Analytics

Management Interface (`notifications/views.py`)

Dashboard Views:

MessageDashboardView - Statistics, charts, recent messages
MessageAnalyticsView - Detailed analytics and reports

Message Management:

MessageListView - List with filtering and search
MessageDetailView - Full message details and timeline
MessageExportView - CSV export
MessageRetryView - Retry failed messages

Template Management:

TemplateListView - List all templates
TemplateDetailView - Template details and usage stats
TemplateCreateView - Create new template
TemplateUpdateView - Edit template
TemplateDeleteView - Delete template
TemplateToggleView - Activate/deactivate
TemplateTestView - Test with sample data

Bulk Messaging:

BulkMessageView - Send to multiple recipients

Status: Backend 100% complete, Frontend templates 10% complete

2. Celery Tasks (`core/tasks.py`)

Email Tasks:

send_email_task() - Send plain email
send_template_email_task() - Send using Django template

SMS/WhatsApp Tasks:

send_sms_task() - Send SMS via Twilio
send_whatsapp_task() - Send WhatsApp via Twilio

In-App Notification Tasks:

create_notification_task() - ❌ BROKEN - References non-existent model
send_multi_channel_notification_task() - Multi-channel delivery

Maintenance Tasks:

cleanup_old_notifications() - Clean up old read notifications

3. Appointment Lifecycle Notifications (`appointments/signals.py`)

Automatic Notifications Triggered:

Event	Notification Type	Recipients	Channels
New Appointment	In-app + Email	Provider	In-app, Email
Confirmed	Multi-channel	Patient	SMS/WhatsApp, Email, In-app
Rescheduled	Multi-channel	Patient + Provider	SMS/WhatsApp, Email, In-app
Patient Arrived	In-app	Provider	In-app
In Progress	Log only	-	-
Completed	Email	Patient	Email
Cancelled	Multi-channel	Patient + Provider	SMS/WhatsApp, Email, In-app
No-Show	Email + In-app	Patient + Provider	Email, In-app

Signal Handlers:

- appointment_pre_save()     # Auto-generate appointment number
- appointment_post_save()    # Trigger notifications
- create_subfile_if_needed() # Auto-create patient sub-file
- notify_provider_new_appointment()
- create_patient_confirmation_token()
- schedule_appointment_reminders()
- handle_appointment_confirmed()
- handle_appointment_rescheduled()
- handle_appointment_arrived()
- handle_appointment_in_progress()
- handle_appointment_completed()
- handle_appointment_cancelled()
- handle_appointment_no_show()

4. Appointment Reminder System (`appointments/tasks.py`)

Scheduled Reminders:

24-hour reminder before appointment
2-hour reminder before appointment
Automatic cancellation on appointment changes

Reminder Channels:

Determined by patient preferences
Default: SMS
Fallback: WhatsApp → Email

❌ Critical Gaps Identified

1. Missing In-App Notification Model

Problem: The create_notification_task() function in core/tasks.py attempts to import:

from notifications.models import Notification  # ❌ This model doesn't exist

Impact:

All in-app notifications are failing silently
Staff members receive no internal notifications
System relies entirely on external channels (email/SMS)
Provider alerts not working
Patient arrival notifications not working
Status change notifications not working

Evidence:

# core/tasks.py line 150
@shared_task(bind=True, max_retries=3)
def create_notification_task(
    self,
    user_id: str,
    title: str,
    message: str,
    notification_type: str = 'INFO',
    related_object_type: Optional[str] = None,
    related_object_id: Optional[str] = None,
) -> bool:
    try:
        from notifications.models import Notification  # ❌ FAILS HERE
        from core.models import User
        
        user = User.objects.get(id=user_id)
        
        notification = Notification.objects.create(  # ❌ NEVER EXECUTES
            user=user,
            title=title,
            message=message,
            notification_type=notification_type,
            related_object_type=related_object_type,
            related_object_id=related_object_id,
        )
        
        logger.info(f"Notification created for user {user_id}: {title}")
        return True
        
    except Exception as exc:
        logger.error(f"Failed to create notification: {exc}")
        raise self.retry(exc=exc, countdown=60)

Required Fix: Create Notification model in notifications/models.py with fields:

user (ForeignKey to User)
title (CharField)
message (TextField)
notification_type (CharField with choices: INFO, WARNING, ERROR, SUCCESS)
is_read (BooleanField)
read_at (DateTimeField, nullable)
related_object_type (CharField, nullable)
related_object_id (UUIDField, nullable)
created_at (DateTimeField)
updated_at (DateTimeField)

2. Missing Notification Center UI

Problem: No user interface for staff to view in-app notifications

Required Components:

Bell icon in header with unread count badge
Dropdown notification list
Mark as read functionality
Link to related objects (appointments, invoices, etc.)
Notification preferences page
Notification history page

3. Incomplete Frontend Templates

Status: 9 templates pending (only dashboard.html completed)

Missing Templates:

message_list.html - Message list view
message_detail.html - Message detail view
template_list.html - Template list view
template_detail.html - Template detail view
template_form.html - Template create/edit form
template_confirm_delete.html - Template deletion confirmation
template_test.html - Template testing interface
bulk_message.html - Bulk messaging interface
analytics.html - Analytics dashboard
partials/message_list_partial.html - HTMX partial

📋 Notification Types

External (Patient-Facing)

Appointment Reminders
- Automated 24 hours before
- Automated 2 hours before
- Respects patient preferences
- Multi-channel delivery
Appointment Confirmations
- On booking
- On confirmation
- Includes appointment details
Rescheduling Notices
- New date/time
- Reason for change
- Confirmation request
Cancellation Notices
- Cancellation reason
- Rescheduling instructions
Completion Receipts
- Thank you message
- Next steps
Billing Notifications
- Invoice generation
- Payment reminders
- Payment confirmations
Marketing Communications
- Optional (preference-based)
- Promotional offers
- Health tips

Internal (Staff-Facing)

New Appointment Alerts
- Provider notifications
- Appointment details
- Patient information
Patient Arrival Alerts
- Front desk → Provider
- Financial clearance status
- Consent verification status
Status Change Alerts
- Appointment lifecycle updates
- Rescheduling notifications
- Cancellation notifications
System Alerts
- Errors
- Warnings
- Info messages

🔧 Technical Implementation Details

Message Template System

Variable Substitution:

# Template definition
template.body_en = "Hi {patient_name}, your appointment is on {date} at {time}"
template.variables = ['patient_name', 'date', 'time']

# Rendering
context = {
    'patient_name': 'Ahmed Al-Saud',
    'date': '2025-11-15',
    'time': '10:00 AM'
}
rendered = template.render(language='en', **context)
# Result: "Hi Ahmed Al-Saud, your appointment is on 2025-11-15 at 10:00 AM"

Bilingual Support:

English: body_en field
Arabic: body_ar field with RTL support
Automatic language selection based on patient preference

Patient Notification Preferences

Controllable Settings:

Channel Preferences:
- SMS enabled/disabled
- WhatsApp enabled/disabled
- Email enabled/disabled
Notification Types:
- Appointment reminders
- Appointment confirmations
- Results notifications
- Billing notifications
- Marketing communications
Language & Channel:
- Preferred language (EN/AR)
- Preferred channel (SMS/WhatsApp/Email)

Preference Checking:

# In MessagingService
def _check_patient_preferences(patient_id, channel, notification_type):
    prefs = NotificationPreference.objects.get(patient_id=patient_id)
    return prefs.can_send(channel, notification_type)

Message Delivery Tracking

Status Lifecycle:

QUEUED → SENT → DELIVERED → READ
         ↓
       FAILED (with retry logic, max 3 attempts)
         ↓
       BOUNCED (permanent failure)

Audit Trail:

MessageLog records every state transition
Provider responses stored in JSON
Error messages captured
Retry attempts tracked
Timestamps for each event

Example Timeline:

1. Created      - 2025-11-02 10:00:00
2. Queued       - 2025-11-02 10:00:01
3. Sending      - 2025-11-02 10:00:02
4. Sent         - 2025-11-02 10:00:03 (Provider: Twilio, SID: SM123...)
5. Delivered    - 2025-11-02 10:00:15 (Confirmed by provider)
6. Read         - 2025-11-02 10:05:30 (WhatsApp read receipt)

Retry Logic

Automatic Retries:

Max 3 retry attempts
Exponential backoff (60s, 120s, 240s)
Only for FAILED status
Manual retry available via UI

Retry Conditions:

def can_retry(self):
    return self.status == Message.Status.FAILED and self.retry_count < 3

📈 Analytics & Reporting

Available Metrics

Dashboard Statistics:

Total messages sent
Success rate (%)
Messages by status (Queued, Sent, Delivered, Failed)
Messages by channel (SMS, WhatsApp, Email)
Daily trend (last 7 days)

Analytics Dashboard:

Delivery rate charts
Channel comparison
Daily/weekly/monthly trends
Top templates by usage
Cost analysis (per message, per channel)
Failure analysis

Export Capabilities:

CSV export of message history
Filtered exports (date range, channel, status, template)
Includes all message details and timestamps

Sample Analytics Query

# Get statistics for last 7 days
stats = MessagingService().get_message_statistics(
    tenant_id=tenant_id,
    days=7
)

# Returns:
{
    'total': 1250,
    'by_channel': {
        'SMS': 800,
        'WHATSAPP': 350,
        'EMAIL': 100
    },
    'by_status': {
        'DELIVERED': 1150,
        'FAILED': 50,
        'QUEUED': 50
    },
    'success_rate': 92.0
}

🔐 Security & Permissions

Role-Based Access Control

Notification Management:

Admin: Full access (create, edit, delete templates, send bulk messages)
Front Desk: View messages, send individual messages, retry failed
Provider: View own notifications only
Patient: View own messages only (future feature)

Tenant Isolation:

All queries filtered by tenant
Multi-tenancy enforced at model level
No cross-tenant data access

Audit Logging:

All administrative actions logged
User, timestamp, action type recorded
Changes tracked for compliance

📁 Key Files Reference

Models

notifications/models.py - External notification models (MessageTemplate, Message, NotificationPreference, MessageLog)
❌ Missing: In-app Notification model

Services

integrations/messaging_service.py - Main messaging API (500+ lines)
integrations/sms_providers.py - Provider abstraction layer
core/tasks.py - Celery tasks for async notifications

Signal Handlers

appointments/signals.py - Appointment lifecycle notifications (600+ lines)
finance/signals.py - Financial notifications (if exists)
core/signals.py - Core model signals

Views

notifications/views.py - Notification management views (800+ lines)
notifications/forms.py - Forms for templates and messages
notifications/urls.py - URL routing

Templates

notifications/templates/notifications/dashboard.html - ✅ Complete
notifications/templates/notifications/*.html - ❌ 9 templates pending

Tasks

appointments/tasks.py - Appointment-specific tasks (reminders, confirmations)
integrations/tasks.py - Integration tasks (provider sync)

📊 Implementation Completeness Matrix

Component	Status	Completion	Priority
External Notifications
- Message Models	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Message Templates	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Delivery Tracking	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Patient Preferences	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Messaging Service	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Provider Integration	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Retry Logic	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Bulk Messaging Backend	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Analytics Backend	✅ Complete	100%	-
Internal Notifications
- In-App Notification Model	❌ Missing	0%	🔴 Critical
- Notification Tasks	⚠️ Broken	0%	🔴 Critical
- Notification Center UI	❌ Missing	0%	🟡 High
Frontend
- Dashboard Template	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Message Templates	❌ Missing	0%	🟡 High
- Template Templates	❌ Missing	0%	🟡 High
- Bulk Messaging Template	❌ Missing	0%	🟡 High
- Analytics Template	❌ Missing	0%	🟢 Medium
- HTMX Partials	❌ Missing	0%	🟢 Medium
Integration
- Appointment Signals	✅ Complete	100%	-
- Celery Tasks	✅ Complete	100%	-
- URL Routing	✅ Complete	100%	-

Overall Completion: 70%

🚨 Critical Issues Summary

Issue #1: Missing In-App Notification Model

Severity: 🔴 Critical
Impact: All internal staff notifications failing
Affected Features:
- Provider appointment alerts
- Patient arrival notifications
- Status change notifications
- System alerts
Fix Required: Create Notification model
Estimated Effort: 1-2 hours

Issue #2: No Notification Center UI

Severity: 🟡 High
Impact: Staff cannot view notifications
Affected Users: All staff members
Fix Required: Build notification center interface
Estimated Effort: 3-4 hours

Issue #3: Incomplete Frontend Templates

Severity: 🟡 High
Impact: Cannot manage messages/templates via UI
Affected Features: Message management, template management, bulk messaging
Fix Required: Create 9 missing templates
Estimated Effort: 2-3 hours

💡 Recommendations

Immediate Actions (Priority 1)

Create In-App Notification Model
- Add to notifications/models.py
- Create migration
- Update admin interface
- Test with existing signal handlers
Build Notification Center UI
- Bell icon in header with badge
- Dropdown notification list
- Mark as read functionality
- Link to related objects
Complete Frontend Templates
- Message list and detail views
- Template management views
- Bulk messaging interface

Short-Term Improvements (Priority 2)

Real-Time Notifications
- Implement WebSockets (Django Channels)
- Or use HTMX polling for updates
- Push notifications to browser
Enhanced Analytics
- Engagement metrics (open rates, click rates)
- Cost analysis by department
- Provider performance metrics
Notification Preferences UI
- Staff notification preferences
- Quiet hours configuration
- Notification grouping

Long-Term Enhancements (Priority 3)

Advanced Features
- Message scheduling
- Template versioning
- A/B testing for templates
- Rich media support (images, attachments)
Integration Expansion
- Additional SMS providers
- Push notifications (mobile app)
- Slack/Teams integration
AI/ML Features
- Smart send time optimization
- Predictive delivery success
- Automated template suggestions

🎯 Conclusion

The AgdarCentre notification system has a solid foundation with:

✅ Strengths:

Comprehensive external messaging (SMS/WhatsApp/Email)
Robust template system with bilingual support
Detailed delivery tracking and analytics
Patient preference management
Automated appointment lifecycle notifications
Multi-channel delivery with fallback
Retry logic and error handling

❌ Critical Gaps:

In-app notification model missing
Staff cannot receive internal notifications
Notification center UI not implemented
Frontend templates incomplete

Overall Assessment: The external notification system is production-ready and well-implemented. However, the internal notification system has a critical flaw that prevents staff from receiving in-app notifications. This should be addressed immediately to ensure proper staff communication.

Recommended Next Steps:

Create the missing Notification model (1-2 hours)
Build notification center UI (3-4 hours)
Complete frontend templates (2-3 hours)
Add real-time notification delivery (4-6 hours)

Total Estimated Effort: 10-15 hours to reach 100% completion

📞 Support & Documentation

Related Documentation:

NOTIFICATIONS_IMPLEMENTATION_SUMMARY.md - Implementation details
PHASE6_SMS_WHATSAPP_INTEGRATION_COMPLETE.md - SMS/WhatsApp integration
PHASE4_STATE_MACHINE_NOTIFICATIONS_COMPLETE.md - State machine notifications

Key Contacts:

Backend: integrations/messaging_service.py
Frontend: notifications/views.py
Signals: appointments/signals.py
Tasks: core/tasks.py

Report Generated: November 2, 2025
Version: 1.0
Status: Complete

21 KiB Raw Blame History